Peer feedback in the international classroom

  • Hoger onderwijs
  • Peer feedback can cause discomfort and uneasiness to students from collectivist cultures. To overcome these kinds of struggles, project developed a trajectory and products to use peer feedforward instead of peer feedback.

    Bijdrage van MA. Jannemieke Geessink (HAN University of Applied Sciences) Meer informatie

    Gepubliceerd:

    Cultural differences in peer feedback

    The project team started this project because students appear to differ in their feedback to each other. This difference seemed to be linked to their cultural backgrounds. Also, students in an international classroom communicate in a language that is not their mother tongue and which they master at different levels. All this can make it difficult for them to formulate peer feedback in a good way.

    These differences and difficulties are unfortunate, because peer feedback can be a powerful instrument for learning. Students of the International School of Business give feedback to group members during their first-year project work. This feedback focuses on individual behaviour during group work.

    To overcome the cultural differences, the main aim of this project was to develop a more inclusive feedback process. Therefore, the project team investigated through interviews which criteria students of different cultures consider important in group work and which individual skills they believe are important. A final goal of the project was to gain insight into the possible contribution of peer feedback to the development of intercultural awareness.

    Discomfort and uneasiness cause intercultural differences

    Outcomes of the interviews with students revealed that unfamiliarity with the feedback instrument is one of the reasons for the cultural differences. For students from collectivist cultures, the almost counterintuitive approach of providing peer feedback on individual behaviour during group work causes discomfort and uneasiness.

    These interviews were semi-structured and in-depth and were carried out with thirteen students. Seven of these thirteen students came from collectivist cultures and six from individualistic cultures. In total nine nationalities were represented.

    Develop feedforward trajectory instead of feedback

    The project team concluded that the peer feedback process should have a gradual structure in which students also feel safe. In addition, they decided to develop a ‘feedforward trajectory’ instead of the planned feedback process. This was based on the interview outcomes and on insights about the use of peer feedforward as a valuable element in the peer learning process (Hattie & Timperley, 2007). The gradual build-up means that students first give peer feedforward on a product, then on their joint group process and finally on individual behaviour/skills.

    For students to be able to give feedforward, the project team developed lists of criteria. During feedforward on joint group processes and on individual behaviour/skills, students choose which criteria they want to give or receive feedforward on. Students exchange the criteria in dialogue, discussing the motivation for their choices and the feedforward. This dialogue is thought to stimulate critical thinking, question one's ideas and insights, stimulate curiosity and allow to view the world from others’ perspectives.

    Besides the lists of criteria, the project team developed other products to support the feedforward trajectory. These are a training module, various manuals for teachers and students and a glossary to help students formulate the feedforward in a neutral, non-offensive way.

    Testing shows student improve in understanding other cultures

    The developed products were tested by means of surveys and observations. The process of testing was planned in a few offline classes, but the Covid-19 pandemic interrupted this. So, the products were tested in online project classes.

    During testing, the project team realised a change and a problem with the original plan. The change was made to the used methodology. By interviewing fourth-year students that graduated during the research process, the project team realised that they used an embedded case study design instead of the planned action research. The problem with the original plan was that it would be impossible to isolate the effect of the peer feedforward instrument on intercultural skills development. All students in the programme follow classes on intercultural awareness and study in an international environment which constantly influences their intercultural awareness.

    Although the contribution of the instrument was hard to measure, the students indicated that the exchange of chosen criteria and motives helped them to understand other cultures. Also, the students believed that providing peer feedforward in the designed way appeals to intercultural skills. The glossary gave particularly first-year students confidence in formulating feedforward for their peers.

    Programme change and Covid were challenging

    The project team experienced two challenges during the project. First, the International Business programme changed. No longer did students work together in a project group for one semester, but they worked together for only six weeks. This means that the students had to provide feedforward to each other already after three weeks, because then they still had time to make use of the feedforward. This shorter period implied that the whole process from training to intentions for improvement also had to be concluded in a shorter period, resulting in less attention for completion of the process in the right way.

    A second challenge was the Covid-19 pandemic. This caused that the project team could not complete the first round of testing. But the team dealt with this challenge by testing online groups a few semesters later.

    Results sustainably applied in other modules and a learning line

    The results of this project will be continued within the institution in several ways. These are:

    1. The results will be further implemented in the programme.
    2. There are thoughts about implementation of a learning line ‘Peer feedforward’.
    3. The training will be included in ‘Personal and Professional Development’.
    4. The feedforward process developed in this project will be used in at least two of the four project modules.
    5. Peer feedback was an important component in the fourth-year research module, but this is replaced now by peer feedforward.
    6. Implementation of peer feedforward on process has taken place in the elective ‘Crossing Borders Without Crossing Borders’.
    7. In the modules ‘Business Project Management’ and ‘Event Management’ peer feedforward is used on a product and alternatively on the group process or on individual behaviour.
    8. Finally, various programmes within and outside the institution use the developed products and/or insights.

    Five most relevant publications for this project

    • Deardorff, D. K. (2006). Identification and assessment of intercultural competence as a student outcome of internationalization. Journal of Studies in International Education, 10(3), 241-226.
    • Hattie, J., & Timperley, H. (2007). The power of feedback. Review of educational research, 77(1), 81-112.
    • Latifi, S., Noroozi, O., & Talaee, E (2021). Peer feedback or peer feedforward? Enhancing students’ argumentative peer learning processes and outcomes. British Journal of Educational Technology, 52(2), 768–784
    • Liu, N. F., & Carless, D. (2006). Peer feedback: the learning element of peer assessment. Teaching in Higher education, 11(3), 279-290.
    • Van Popta, E., Kral, M., Camp, G., Martens, R. L., & Simons, P. R. J. (2017). Exploring the value of peer feedback in online learning for the provider. Educational Research Review, 20, 24-34.

    Products and publications from the project

    Article: Van Rompay-Bartels, I., & Geessink, J. (2021). Exploring peer feedback on behaviour in the international classroom: a case study on students’ experiences and perceptions. Journal of International Education in Business.

    Website: https://peer-feedback-in-the-international-classroom.jimdosite.com  Products are available through this website.

    Comenius Teaching Fellow

    Bijdrage van

    MA. Jannemieke Geessink

    MA. Jannemieke Geessink

    Ph.D. kandidaat

    HAN University of Applied Sciences

    Mogen we je iets vragen?

    Ga je deze informatie gebruiken in het onderwijs?
    Wat vind je van de leesbaarheid van deze pagina?
    In welke onderwijssector werk je?

    Wil je nog iets anders kwijt? Laat het ons weten via het feedback-formulier.

    Privacyverklaring

    Wij gaan zorgvuldig om met persoonsgegevens. Lees hierover meer in onze privacyverklaring.

    Gerelateerd in de kennisbank

    • Placeholder Onderwijskennis.nl

      Verdiepende bron

      Studieloopbaanbegeleiding in het hbo

      ho

      Als onderdeel van het project om studieloopbaanbegeleiding (SLB) te vernieuwen en verbeteren schreef Saxion Hogescholen een nieuwe visie op en bouwstenen voor SLB.

      Lees verder
    • Placeholder Onderwijskennis.nl

      Praktijkvoorbeeld

      Rotterdamse Aanpak: doorstroom mbo-hbo

      ho

      In ‘De Rotterdamse aanpak’ hebben drie roc’s en twee hogescholen gezamenlijk een "keuzedeel voorbereiding hbo" ontwikkeld om de doorstroom in het economisch domein te verbeteren.

      Lees verder
    • Praktijkvoorbeeld

      Inclusie: Meer dan het omgaan met verschillen

      ho

      Voor inclusief onderwijs is kritisch zelfonderzoek nodig. Dit is onderzoek naar de eigen overtuigingen over inclusie en diversiteit. In dit project zijn leeractiviteiten ontwikkeld die helpen bij...